Critical Issue Speeches

Child Soldier Debate!!

Today's debate format is set up in a way that will help you write your argument essay over the weekend. Rounds 2 and 3 are specifically designed to lay the groundwork for the counterargument section of your essay. Remember, there are two objectives in a counterclaim. #1 poke holes in your opponent's theory. #2 play defense for your own theory. 

Avoid words that don't further your argument. For example, people who believe child soldiers are criminals should avoid using the words victim or brainwashing whenever possible. 

Take words or phrases that your opponent used in their initial argument, and turn them around to use their own words against them. Redefine the circumstances to better align with your theory. For example, someone who believes that child soldiers are perpetrators could question the use of the word "victim," and remind their opponent of all the innocent "victims" the child soldiers killed in incredibly brutal ways. 

As you write your argument essay supporting whichever side you support on this issue... be sure to use the notes you have from the debate activity. What are the most relevant pieces of evidence to support your thesis.

     Choose a thesis:

1. Child soldiers should be prosecuted for their crimes, because they are perpetrators.
2. Child "soldiers" should not be prosecuted for their "crimes," because they are victims of horrific circumstances.

Debate preparations...

Child Soldiers in the Ranks

Critical Issue Research

Use the links below to gather information and take notes to answer the following questions:

Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes? 

Are they victims? 

Are they perpetrators?

CNN video- Youngest Guantanamo detainee transferred

CBS News Video- Eye To Eye: Ishmael Beah (CBS News)

Click on the article links below for more information:

A child soldier interrogated and tried

Analysis: Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes?

Victims, perpetrators, or heroes?

Armed & Underage

Koinange: Friend gunned down by child soldiers

Working through our nonfiction reading

Anyone up for a little Nonfiction Tic-Tac-Toe??

A printable copy of the Tic-Tac-Toe board is available on my homework page.

Tic-Tac-Toe Board

Frayer Model Format

Non-fiction Do's

Winter SRI Test!

Take your time and do your very best work!!

SRI Test Link